35c. A President Impeached

Johnson receives summons
Johnson's response to his impeachment was, "Let them impeach, and be damned."

In the spring of 1868, Andrew Johnson became the first President to be impeached. The heavily Republican House of Representatives brought 11 articles of impeachment against Johnson. Many insiders knew that the Congress was looking for any excuse to rid themselves of an uncooperative President.

Impeachment refers to the process specified in the Constitution for trial and removal from office of any federal official accused of misconduct. It has two stages. The House of Representatives charges the official with articles of impeachment. "Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors" are defined as impeachable offenses. Once charged by the House, the case goes before the Senate for a trial.

Sampson Agonistes at Washington
In this cartoon, President Johnson is depicted as Sampson, tearing down the temple whose pillars read, "Stanton," "Reconstruction," and "Sheridan."

In 1867, Congress passed the Reconstruction Act, which Edwin Stanton, as Secretary of War, was charged with enforcing. Johnson opposed the Act and tried to remove Stanton — in direct violation of the Tenure of Office Act. Nine of the articles of impeachment related to Johnson's removal of Stanton. Another two charged Johnson with disgracing Congress.

Johnson's defense was simple: only a clear violation of the law warranted his removal.

Johnson's Impeachment

Should Johnson have been removed from office when he was impeached?



But as with politics, things are rarely simple. Other factors came into play. Since there was no Vice President at the time, the next in line for the Presidency was Benjamin Wade, a Radical unpopular with businessmen and moderates. And along with legal wrangling, assurance was given from Johnson's backers that the Radicals' Southern policies would be accepted.

In May of 1868, 35 Senators voted to convict, one vote short of the required 2/3 majority. Seven Republican Senators had jumped party lines and found Johnson not guilty. Johnson dodged a bullet and was able to serve out his term. It would be 130 years before another President — Bill Clinton — would be impeached.
On the Web
Senate Impeachment Trial
From: Eric Foner's Reconstruction America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877 the tale of Johnson's impeachment trial. Foner is able to convey complex topics in language that's easy to understand. Foner comes at the impeachment trial from many angles and he includes fun things like bookmakers' odds on acquittal.
The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson
A remarkable resource from Harper's Weekly a magazine that actually covered Johnson's impeachment in 1869. Key political issues affecting the impeachment and explanations of four central subjects influencing the political environment of the impeachment are examined. Understand the legal, political and Constitutional arguments for and against Impeachment — made by key Congressmen, defense counsel and newspaper editors. There's a fabulous " Who Was Who" featuring of 28 important figures in the impeachment drama. The site also features 90 Editorials by George William Curtis, 47 News Articles and Briefs, 47 Illustrations of People and Events, 27 Political Cartoons by Thomas Nast and Others. These pieces were written by reporters actually covering the trial. And there are pictures galore! One of the great sites on the Internet.
The Tenure of Office Act
Part of the reason Andrew Johnson was impeached was for violating the Tenure of Office Act. Find out about what the act was and the role it played in Johnson's impeachment.
Take an interactive impeachment quiz put together by the Washington Post. Questions deal with Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and the nature of impeachment.
Learn More...
This is an opportunity for you and your class to retry President Andrew Johson. Just follow these instructions for the "Impeachment Simulation Game."
Learn More... Facebook Digg Furl Netscape Yahoo! My Web StumbleUpon Google Bookmarks Technorati BlinkList Newsvine ma.gnolia reddit Windows Live